It’s strange how my more socialist stripes come out sometimes. Sort of.
Some good news regarding the film industry in Canada. The Senate has amended a bill which would have essentially given the government power to deny funding to film projects it deemed ‘against the public interest’. In effect, being that the current government has a number of kooky religious types in it’s midst, this would have been a leverage tool to promote family values pap (read: propaganda) and pushing out more cutting edge, progressive, and experimental film projects.
Which brings me to the irony. The party that pushed this bill was elected. The Senate is appointed and currently has a majority from the opposition party. Therefore it was the appointed segment of government that upheld the rights of free expression against the party elected by the people.
Now, keep in mind there are serious issues with just how representative the Canadian system really is. But proportional representation is a whole other kettle of fish.
I know there are libertarian objections to any government having any say in the production of cultural artifacts such as films, whether that is through censorship or through funding. These folks would have the market decide things, I suppose.
I’m not opposed to getting the government entirely out of the picture, but we should be talking grass-roots productions and community support. Even then though, resources are often scarce for idiosyncratic visions.
Here is where at least for myself, I experience a higher standard of cultural production from the state-run rather than the market-run institutions in Canada.
In recent weeks I have been re-introduced to the train wreck that is commercial radio, through my current place of employment. The same ten songs or so have echoed in continuous rotation dozens and dozens (and yet more dozens) of times. Coupled with inane and unlistenable commercials, it really is a chore to digest any of it.
Okay well, the atrocity that is commercial radio is self-evident. But it is also a product of the market as it functions in effect, not in theory.
Public and campus radio offer nooks and crannies to discover, items to offend and challenge and inform and soothe and pretty much do anything but turn your mind off.
Dirty state-run commie radio.
As a side note, let this also be a warning as certain public broadcasters continue to tread deeper into corporate territory, courting a fictional youth demographic at the expense of long-standing quality programming.
Just stop. Please.
I still lament the loss of Brave New Waves, I admit it.
So yes… the irony is, unelected senators do good and state-run media provide content far more engaging and critical than most commercial outlets. In Canada, I’m pretty sure that’s all commercial outlets.
I have not touched on web-based media, of course. Another topic for another time, but the anarchic potential of the Web is duly noted, if not expanded upon for now.